The 5 Great Roads of Ancient Ireland: Fact or Medieval Fiction?

The Rath of Synods at the Hill of Tara. (c) Ali Isaac

According to legend, there were five great roads which led to the Hill of Tara. One of them runs between the north and south campuses of my university at Maynooth, and I’ve been crossing it almost every day for the last two years. Of course, it looks a bit different today; it’s tarmacked for a start, cars drive along it instead of carts, and it has rather a lot of traffic lights. You can read more about the five great roads in my post, The Ancient Origins of the Irish Road, but since then I’ve learned a whole lot more about them which I’d like to share.

It has always been believed that the Hill of Tara was the royal residence of the High Kings of Ireland; after all, we have inherited a vast wealth of early Medieval literature which tells us so. However, since the 1980s, a new school of thought began to emerge which interpreted these medieval tales as a reflection of the times they were written rather than the Iron Age which they claim to portray.


Mound of hostages, black and white images, people standing on top of it.

Mound of hostages at Tara. (c) Ali Isaac


When you look at what was going on in Ireland during the Medieval period, this concept cannot be denied, but I also think these early writers were building on something which was already in existence: non-literate societies share their knowledge, learning and history through an oral tradition, and there is no reason to suppose that the people of Ireland’s pre-history were any different.

In 1992, the Discovery Research Programme found that the archaeology at Tara did not support the literature; there was no evidence of habitation, and in fact the presence of burials, combined with the density and complexity of other structures, and lack of defensive features suggested instead a ritual purpose.

It also shares similarities with other so called ‘royal sites’ at Cruachan in Connacht, Emain Macha in Ulster, and Dún Ailline in Leinster, such as the conjoined figure-of-eight mounds accompanied by the close proximity of a burial mound, both located within a wide, circular embankment and ditch.


Rath Mor at Cruachan, home of legendary Queen Medb. (c) Ali Isaac

Rath Mor at Cruachan, home of legendary Queen Medb. (c) Ali Isaac


In addition, archaeology revealed something else; that all these sites shared a mysterious decommissioning process around the year 96BC. It seems each site was buried beneath a layer of stones and boulders, the whole thing set alight, and then, when the embers had died down, the whole site was covered in earth. It was, in effect, a triple death, something which has been interpreted as  a great sacrifice when applied to people, as described in literature, and as discovered during the study of various bog bodies.

Another feature shared by these ‘royal sites’, but less sensational and certainly long neglected, is their connection via a system of five great roads, which according to early Irish literature, appear to centre on the Hill of Tara.

This is what the Annals of the Four Masters has to say about them:


The night of Conn’s birth [Conn Cétchathach, meaning ‘of the Hundred battles] were discovered five principal roads leading to Teamhair [Irish for Tara] which were never observed till then. These are their names: Slighe Asail, Slighe Midhluachra, Slighe Cualann, Slighe Mor, Slighe Dala. Slighe Mor is that called Eisir Riada, i.e. the division line of Ireland into two parts, between Conn and Eoghan Mor (AFM M123.2).


Although travel is frequently mentioned in early Irish literature, with stopping points and places of habitation along routes being named, the roads taken are not. ‘The Destruction of Da Derga’s Hostel’ is an exception; it mentions ‘the four [not five] roads whereby men go to Tara’, naming two of them later in the story when Conaire breaks his kingly geisa, or taboos:


Great fear then fell on Conaire because they had no way to wend save upon the Road of Midluachair and the Road of Cualu (CELT).


Could these roads mentioned in early Medieval writings have existed in pre-historic times? For an answer, we need to turn to the archaeological evidence.

George Petrie was an Irish artist and antiquarian who travelled the length and breadth of Ireland, recording the land’s ancient monuments. In 1839, he was commissioned by the Irish Ordinance Survey to conduct a survey of the Hill of Tara, which was later published by the Royal Irish Academy. His plan clearly shows all five roads as named in the Annals.


20180630_2253274187923618480289108.jpg


According to scholar DL Swan, these roads ‘correspond closely to the main road system at present in use’. However, he claims the evidence upon which Petrie based his map is not clear, and that he cited none at all for his plotting of the Slighe Cualann.

By contrast, Colm O’Lochlainn‘s study, ‘Roadways in Ancient Ireland’ (1940) upon which most contemporary works are modelled, focused on journeys in early Irish literature, particularly ‘The Tripartite Life of St. Patrick’, the Tain bo Cuailnge, Mesca Ulaidh, Acaldamh na Senórach, the Book of Lismore, and others.

He marked these routes on a map upon which he had already identified place names associated with travel, such as ath– a ford; droichead – a bridge; bealach– a gap/ passage; and bóchar– a cattle track, amongst others. The results led him to identify the five great roads, but with one huge difference: they centred on Dublin not Tara, and as we all know, Dublin did not become a major centre until the Vikings in the mid ninth century.


The Hill of Tara. (c) Ali Isaac

The Hill of Tara. (c) Ali Isaac


DL Swan’s aerial photography identifies a series of linear depressions which correspond with Petrie’s plan. He also makes a very interesting observation; he claims they all align with the feature known as the Teach Miodhchuarta, or Banqueting Hall, stating that ‘regardless of which route one uses to approach the hill, the final approach can be made via the Teach Miodhchuarta’.

This monument is thought to be one of the oldest structures at Tara, dating to 2700BC. Early Irish literature portrays this feature as the setting for each reigning High King’s feasts; in fact, a drawing from the Leabhar Glinne Dá Locha (the Book of Glendalough, dating to the twelfth century but gathered from earlier sources) goes so far as to present a seating plan for the king and his guests.

Today, this feature is recognised as a ceremonial processional road by which the monuments on the hill top are approached, a pathway between the physical world and the Otherworld of Tara, between the present and the past. C. Newman specifically links it with the inauguration and burial of kings. He also draws comparisons with the Knockans of Teltown, and the Mucklaghs of Cruachan: they all slope downhill towards what was originally bogland, feature irregularly spaced gaps in their banks, and lack identifiable ditches from which the bank material was dug.


Hill of Tara. www.aliisaacstoryteller.com

The ceremonial processional way known as the Teach Miodhchuarta leading to the summit of the Hill of Tara can clearly be seen at the centre top of this picture.


An excavation of the partially destroyed Knochans in 1997 by Waddell and O’Brien yielded unexpected results, revealing that major structural phases had occurred between AD640-780, and again in AD770-990. Newman claims this has implications for Teach Miodhchuarta and the Mucklaghs: they could be much later additions to the royal complexes than previously thought, suggesting that an early Medieval date ‘connect[s] it [Teach Miodhchuarta] far more definitively with the institution of early Medieval kingship of Tara than if it were already some thousands of years old’.

This, however, poses a problem: at the time when the Knockans were under Medieval renovation, Christian scribes were busy imagining Tara as the royal residence of High Kings, not as a ceremonial centre. If Teach Miodhchuarta was indeed constructed in the early Medieval period, as Newman suggests, then the scribes writing about Tara from the seventh century onwards would have witnessed its construction, or at least have been aware of it and its purpose as the processional way of kings.

It is also possible, though, that the Church was attempting to rebrand Tara even whilst it was still in use, to secure their religious and political goals, such as promoting Christianity, and courting the patronage and favour of the ascending powerful Uí Néill family.


Looking across the Slighe Miluachra towards the approach to Emain Macha.

Looking across the Slighe Miluachra towards the approach to Emain Macha.


A study by P. O’Keeffe in 2001 for the National Roads Authority disagreed with O’Lochlainn and placed the hub of the five ancient roads quite firmly at Tara. He claimed the Slighe Assail connected Tara with Uisneach and Cruachan, that the Slighe Dála passed close to Dún Ailinne, that the Slighe Midhluachra connected Tara with Emain Macha ( I have stood on this road), and that the Slighe Mór only joined the Eisker Riada at Balinasloe.

This indicates that the pre-historic purpose of the road network was to connect the major ancient ritual sites, allowing the flow of communication between the authoritative bodies governing each one, perhaps explaining how they were all decommissioned at the same time.


The ancient oak planks of the great Corlea Trackway.

The ancient oak planks of the great Corlea Trackway.


However, as L. Doran notes, these roads were ‘not physical entities but rights of way with legal staus’, meaning that it is unlikely travellers would have been able to travel along them in chariots at great speed as depicted in the stories of the Tain, for example, where warriors traversed the distance between Emain Macha and Cruachain in less than a day.

The terrain would have had to have been modified to accommodate them. In the minds of the writers of these stories, however, such travel seemed perfectly feasible, suggesting that by the early Medieval period, when the stories were written, the rights of way had been superseded by roads which certainly were capable of supporting wheeled traffic and horses.

Whilst the main factor shaping the road network was the location of the ‘royal sites’, by the early modern period they served an additional purpose, according to L. Doran, one which may explain the upgrading of the rights of way into surfaced roads: they connected isolated areas of Ireland to the east coast and continental markets, bringing commerce and wealth and thereby the means, and the necessity for, providing better roads.



Whilst presenting a logical progression, Doran’s theories are based on O’Lochlainn’s model, and completely disregard the importance of Tara as the central hub of the road network, which the compilers of the annals and the Christian scribes of the early Medieval period were keen to point out.

This ancient road system continued to be of use throughout the Medieval period and beyond, as can be seen in the number of Anglo-Norman castles, mottes and settlements at fords and crossing places along the Slighe Mór and Slighe Assail. HC Lawlor in an earlier study traced the route of the Slighe Miluachra through Ulster by identifying river fords. Situating one’s castle at a fording point gave the owner strategic advantage, both militarily and commercially, in terms of controlling access to the river, an important artery of transport and communication, and also to the road.



We can see this at Clonmacnoise, an early Medieval ecclesiastical site located at the intersection of the River Shannon and the Slighe Mór, also known as the Pilgrim’s Way. The remains of a wooden bridge dating to the ninth century were discovered at the ford beside the monastery, making it, as Doran says, ‘the earliest known bridge in Ireland and also the largest free-standing wooden structure in early Medieval Ireland’. This bridge undoubtedly provided a means of control and revenue for the community of monks at Clonmacnoise.

So, whilst it seems that there is indeed enough archaeological and literary evidence to support the existence of some level of road network extending from the pre-historic era into medieval Ireland, scholars are divided on the exact routes and the location of the central hub, either Tara or Dublin.


Medb's Fort at Cruachan.

Medb’s Fort at Cruachan.


Most are agreed, though, that they appear to connect the provincial ‘royal sites’, thus corresponding with early literatures, such as the Táin bo Cuailnge. These roads appear to have been developed during Medieval times from rights of way into physical road structures capable of supporting horses and wheeled transport, possibly to facilitate trade and commerce, but also to cope with the increased traffic of pilgrimage where the roads passed by major ecclesiastical sites.

The ‘royal site’ at the Hill of tara also presents a sixth road, as archaeological evidence has facilitated the re-interpretation of the Teach Miodchuarta from a king’s banqueting hall into a ritual processional way by which the summit of the site may be accessed (I will be going into this in a bit more depth in a future post.), and with which all the five great roads connect. Recent archaeological findings at the Knockans, a similar structure at Teltown, have challenged the early dating of this monument at Tara, but remain a somewhat controversial theory as yet unproven.


This post is based on an essay I wrote for ‘The Cultural Heritage of ‘Royal Sites’ module I took last semester.


Refs.
Annals of the Four Masters, M123.2, CELT: The Corpus of Electronic Texts.

Doran, L. 2004 Medieval Communication Routes through Longford and Roscommon and Their Associated Settlements, Proceedings of the Royal Irish Academy: Archaeology, Culture, History,Literature, Vol. 104C, No. 3, 57-80.

Field Seminar to Emain Macha, my notes.

Lawlor, HC 1938 An Ancient Route: The Slighe Miodhluachra in Ulaidh, Ulster Journal of Archaeology, Third Series, Vol. 1, 3-6.

Newman, C. 2007 Procession and Symbolism at Tara: Analysis of Teach Midchuarta (the Banqueting Hall) in the Context of the Sacral Campus, Oxford Journal of Archaeology 26 (4) 415-38.

O’Lochlainn, Colm. 1940. Roadways in Ancient Ireland. In J.Ryan (ed), Féil-Sgribhinn Eóin Mhic Néill: Essays and Studies Presented to Professor Eoin MacNeill, 465-74, Four Courts Press, Dublin.

O’Sullivan, M. and Downey, L. 2015 Early Historic Routeways, Archaeology Ireland, Vol. 29, No.3, 14-17.

Swan, DL. 1978 The Hill of Tara, County Meath: The Evidence of Aerial Photography, The Journal of the Royal Society of Antiquaries of Ireland, Vol. 108, 51-66.

The Destruction of Da Derga’s Hostel, CELT: The Corpus of Electronic Texts.


If you would like to reblog this post, please use the PRESS THIS button. 


thank you for visitingWant more mythology straight to your inbox? Sign up to my mailing list.
Or try one of these…

30 Comments on “The 5 Great Roads of Ancient Ireland: Fact or Medieval Fiction?

  1. Pingback: Processional Pathways of Ancient Ireland | aliisaacstoryteller

    • I know, right? We are discovering more all the time, who knows what secrets will be revealed to us in the future? It’s all very exciting! Thanks for stopping by!

      Liked by 1 person

  2. Loved this post thank you, so interesting. I’m going to forward this to my Aunt Frances, she will love this as the history of her land is so important to her.

    Liked by 1 person

  3. Thanks for sharing! Will save this for future reference. I did a bit of digging (pun intended LOL) myself when I put the Hill of Tara into a short story.

    Like

  4. I’ve always been of the ceremonial site mindset about Tara, and thought that parts of it had special emphasis on fertility. Aerial photographs don’t always illustrate the entire complex, and there are the confounding effects of erosion and changes in vegetation cover, which sometimes make it difficult to visualize relationships between some of the features, but looking at the picture of the map, the cluster of mounds in the center suggests to me a pair of breasts above a uterus with a fetus inside. Now, people in different cultures have looked at the same stars and have seen different constellations in the sky, so not everybody is likely to join up Tara’s dots the same way I do. Whether fertility festivals were held there, or it was a place where newly pregnant women went to worship in hopes of obtaining the blessings of a healthy pregnancy, safe birth, and bountiful milk production, or that the deceased who were buried there were returning their bodies to Mother Earth and hoping for a subsequent rebirth, we’ll never know. But it obviously was a very special place to the ancient community that built and used it, so it makes sense that it would be an important destination to which many roads would lead generations of pilgrims, even though their stories about its meaning evolved over time.

    Liked by 2 people

    • Love that interpretation, Christine! And it’s as valid as any. There are many people who believe the burial mounds represent the womb, and some men wont go in them because they feel they are sacred female spaces. At the end of the day, we can’t really know, because the people who made them left behind no clues as to how they were used, or at least not clues that we can yet understand. You’re right about aerial photography, but it does add an interesting layer of interpretation to a site. Things on the ground can seem pretty random and meaningless until seen from above, just look at the Nasca Lines in Peru. But we also have technologies like LIDAR now which are less invasive than excavation and help archaeologists build up a picture of the parts of structures we can’t see with the naked eye, or that lie below ground, but as with all things, this too relies on interpretation, which no matter how experienced and well meaning, is really just one persons viewpoint, and subject to bias. We know how important fertility was to prehistoric civilisations though, so why not Tara dedicated to the female? Would explain why the Christian church was so keen to rebrand it as the inauguration site or dwelling place of (male) kings! 😂

      Liked by 2 people

      • Maybe Tara, rising above the plain like a pregnant abdomen, was a prehistoric midwifery site. Architectural archaeological findings (such as the remains of post holes) could be evidence of huts where midwives attended birthing women. The womb-and-fetus-like collection of mounds may have been an advert directed towards the heavens, notifying spirits traveling above the earth to “descend and get your mortal body here.” In that case, Tara may be the world’s first lying-in hospital, instead of the Rotunda. (The architecture of the 18th-century hospital also incorporates the pregnant belly look – although predictably dominated by a phallic spire and cupola. Coincidence? Maybe not!) 😀

        Liked by 2 people

        • Hahaha! Brilliant, Christine! Coincidence defo not, I’d say! 😂 But I absolutely love your theory, and so want it to be true. We’ll have to get the feminist archaeologists onto this one… the male ones would never go for it.

          Liked by 1 person

  5. Fascinating to follow (or try to) the various theories. And awesome when you know that you are on a path travelled by the ancients. But Ali, why would roads converge on Dublin before it existed as no more than a minor settlement? (I possibly missed the answer at first reading.)

    Like

    • Exactly, Roy. That’s my point. What the scholars who believe this think is that the roads were created in later medieval times to service commerce and trade. Some archaeology along the routes might shed some light on this. It’s not a coincidence that these routes connect the ancient sites. By the time Dublin became a major centre for trade, there would have been no need or interest in these sites… they were already abandoned and forgotten.

      Liked by 1 person

      • OK yes. And no doubt parts of the oldest routes were duplicated by later ones. And now we have motorways radiating out from Dublin that – I imagine – pretty much mirror the trade routes.

        I’d love to follow the old Butter Road from Castleisland to Cork 🙂

        Liked by 1 person

        • Yes that’s what happened. The motorway from Dublin to Galway is built on part of one of the old roads. Btw, you should do that, Roy. Why not?

          Liked by 1 person

  6. Hi Ali, do you think it’s a pity Ireland hasn’t made a tourist attraction out of the five roads.

    Liked by 2 people

    • Hi Colin, I’m sure stretches of them could be revived. People would love to walk along them, I know I would, following in the footsteps of our ancestors quite literally! The ones I have walked on don’t even have a sign telling you its an ancient road, so you’d never know. That’s the very least which could be done. I’m sure archaeology would throw up some interesting finds. 😊

      Like

Please feel free to join in the conversation...

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

w

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.